Exclusiva vs My Amazon Guy
Done-for-you agency vs a supplement-specialist growth agency. Every fact about My Amazon Guy below comes from its own website or public review platforms, and is dated.
Is Exclusiva a good My Amazon Guy alternative?
Both are done-for-you agencies. The difference is focus. My Amazon Guy serves generalist: Amazon sellers across categories. Exclusiva works only with health, wellness and supplement brands, runs Amazon, TikTok Shop and DTC as one profit system, and offers 23 fixed-price packages so you can start small. If you sell supplements, vitamins or wellness products, choose Exclusiva.
| At a glance | Exclusiva Inc | My Amazon Guy |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Agency (Amazon, TikTok Shop and DTC) | Done-for-you agency |
| Founded | [CONFIRM YEAR] | 2018 |
| Headquarters | Hatfield, PA, USA | Atlanta, GA area |
| Leadership | Mohammed Jamil (Founder & CEO) | Steven Pope (Founder & CEO) |
| Team size | [CONFIRM HEADCOUNT] | Hundreds of staff (its site says 400+ to 500+; Clutch lists 250–999) |
| Focus | Health, wellness and supplement brands only | Generalist: Amazon sellers across categories |
| Channels | Amazon, Walmart, TikTok Shop, Shopify/DTC, Meta, Google | Amazon (Seller + Vendor), Walmart, TikTok Shop, Shopify/DTC, Google, Meta |
| Pricing | AmzRevUp: low base fee + performance component. 23 fixed-price packages from $29, bought online. | Not published; quote on request. Clutch lists $100–$149/hr. |
| Contract / minimum | [CONFIRM TERMS] | Not published; Clutch lists $1,000+ minimum project size. |
| Methods | AmzRevUp, BrandRevUp, 304-point CRO audit, Deterministic Backward Pressure ad testing | 4-phase Amazon SEO plan, main-image "CTR hack", "True ACOS" reporting |
| Public reviews | Clutch 5.0 (5 reviews) | Trustpilot 4.4 (493); no Clutch reviews yet |
| Guarantee | 90-day profit guarantee on AmzRevUp (terms apply) | Not published |
How My Amazon Guy works
My Amazon Guy is a done-for-you agency based in Atlanta, GA area.
It was founded in 2018 and is led by Steven Pope (Founder & CEO).
Its focus, as it describes it: generalist: Amazon sellers across categories. It works across Amazon (Seller + Vendor), Walmart, TikTok Shop, Shopify/DTC, Google, Meta.
What My Amazon Guy offers
- 01Full-service Amazon management
- 02Amazon PPC and DSP
- 03Amazon SEO and listing optimization
- 04Design: A+, brand store, images
- 05Account troubleshooting and reinstatement
- 06Walmart, TikTok Shop and DTC add-ons
What Exclusiva offers
- 01Full-service Amazon (PPC, DSP, SEO, listings, creative, launches, account health, brand protection, reimbursements)
- 02TikTok Shop setup, creators and affiliates
- 03Shopify CRO (304-point audit), offers and landing pages
- 04Klaviyo email and SMS
- 05Meta ads, ad creative and tracking
- 06Supplement claims and compliance reviews
Pricing compared
My Amazon Guy: Not published; quote on request. Clutch lists $100–$149/hr. Contract terms: Not published; Clutch lists $1,000+ minimum project size.
Exclusiva: the AmzRevUp program uses a low base fee plus a performance component, so our fee grows only when your profit does. If you want to start smaller, every service has a fixed-price package (23 in total, from $29) that you can buy online and see delivered before committing to a retainer.
Specialization: why it matters for supplement brands
Supplement and wellness brands face problems most generalist teams only meet occasionally: dietary supplement category approval, Amazon's testing and documentation requirements, structure/function claim rules, meltable-inventory restrictions for gummies and softgels, and TikTok Shop's health-product policies.
My Amazon Guy's stated focus is generalist: Amazon sellers across categories. Exclusiva works only in health, wellness and supplements, so these rules are part of every listing, ad and launch we run, not an exception we look up.
Reviews and reputation
Public reviews for My Amazon Guy: Trustpilot 4.4 (493); no Clutch reviews yet.
Common praise in those reviews: responsive, knowledgeable staff, data-backed explanations, practical PPC, catalog and design results.
Common criticisms: some unanswered follow-ups reported, onboarding and early-termination fees mentioned in reviews, mixed PPC results in isolated reviews.
Exclusiva: 5.0 on Clutch from 5 reviews (quality 4.9, schedule 5.0, cost 4.9, willing to refer 5.0), including supplement brands that report higher ROAS, lower ACoS and multi-channel growth.
My Amazon Guy's own published claims
- 01430+ brands managed (as stated by My Amazon Guy)
- 02$1.2B+ generated on Amazon annually (as stated by My Amazon Guy)
- 03Up to 33X ROAS with DSP (as stated by My Amazon Guy)
Choose Exclusiva if
- 01You sell supplements, vitamins, wellness, beauty or pet health products
- 02You want Amazon, TikTok Shop and Shopify run as one system by one team
- 03You want to be judged on profit, not ad spend
- 04You want to start with a fixed-price package before committing to a retainer
Choose My Amazon Guy if
- 01Amazon-first sellers who want one large generalist agency covering management, PPC/DSP, creative and troubleshooting.
- 02You prefer published starting prices
- 03You operate outside health and wellness
Questions, answered
Is Exclusiva a good My Amazon Guy alternative?
Both are done-for-you agencies. The difference is focus. My Amazon Guy serves generalist: Amazon sellers across categories. Exclusiva works only with health, wellness and supplement brands, runs Amazon, TikTok Shop and DTC as one profit system, and offers 23 fixed-price packages so you can start small. If you sell supplements, vitamins or wellness products, choose Exclusiva.
What is My Amazon Guy?
My Amazon Guy is a done-for-you agency founded in 2018, based in Atlanta, GA area. It focuses on generalist: Amazon sellers across categories.
How much does My Amazon Guy cost?
Not published; quote on request. Clutch lists $100–$149/hr. (as published or listed publicly on October 8, 2026). Exclusiva's packages start at $29 and retainers use a base fee plus performance.
My Amazon Guy vs Exclusiva: which is better for supplement brands?
Exclusiva works only with health, wellness and supplement brands, so compliance, testing and claims rules are built into every listing and ad. My Amazon Guy's published focus is generalist: Amazon sellers across categories.
What do My Amazon Guy reviews say?
Public reviews for My Amazon Guy: Trustpilot 4.4 (493); no Clutch reviews yet. Common praise in those reviews: responsive, knowledgeable staff, data-backed explanations, practical PPC, catalog and design results. Common criticisms: some unanswered follow-ups reported, onboarding and early-termination fees mentioned in reviews, mixed PPC results in isolated reviews.
Can I work with both My Amazon Guy and Exclusiva?
Yes, if the scopes do not overlap, for example their software or consulting for one channel and Exclusiva for another. Most brands consolidate to one team to keep accountability clear.
How did you research this comparison?
Only from public sources: My Amazon Guy's own website and public review platforms, checked on October 8, 2026. Their figures are their own published claims. If something has changed, tell us and we will update the page.
More comparisons
Running a Shopify store too?
BrandRevUp is our growth OS for DTC: the 304-point CRO audit, Deterministic Backward Pressure ad testing and Klaviyo flows.
Find out where your Amazon profit is leaking
Free profit audit from a senior strategist. AmzRevUp is backed by a 90-day profit guarantee.